Opens in a new tab

See YTS In Action

Sequence of Returns Risk: What It Means for Retirees

Sequence of returns risk means the order of returns, not just their average, shapes how long a retirement portfolio lasts. It matters most once withdrawals begin, because selling during a decline leaves fewer shares to take part in any recovery.

For households with $1 million to $5 million, it is often the least visible risk in a retirement income plan. Two portfolios can earn the same average return and still finish decades later in very different places. The hypothetical example below shows how.

What Sequence of Returns Risk Means

Most retirement projections use an average annual return. Real portfolios never earn the average in a straight line. Some years are up, some are down, and the order in which those years arrive is out of anyone’s control.

Why Order Matters Only Once Withdrawals Begin

With no money going in or out, the order of returns does not change the ending balance. A 10 percent gain followed by a 10 percent loss ends in the same place as the reverse. Withdrawals change that math. Money taken out after a loss is gone before any recovery, so it never earns the rebound.

Sequence Risk Compared With Market Volatility

Volatility describes how much returns swing from year to year. Sequence risk describes when those swings happen relative to your withdrawals. A portfolio with ordinary volatility can still face meaningful sequence risk if a decline lands early in retirement.

A Hypothetical Example: Two $2M Portfolios

In this hypothetical, Portfolio A ends year 20 with about $1.81 million. Portfolio B ends with about $3.31 million. Both earned the same returns, in opposite order.

Hypothetical illustration Portfolio A (losses first) Portfolio B (gains first)
Starting balance $2,000,000 $2,000,000
Returns in years 1 to 3 -12%, -8%, -4% 12%, 10%, 9%
Average annual return, years 1 to 20 5.5% 5.5%
Total withdrawn over 20 years $1,600,000 $1,600,000
Balance after 10 years $1,369,777 $3,286,688
Balance after 20 years $1,814,707 $3,310,410

How the Illustration Works

Both portfolios start at $2,000,000 and withdraw $80,000 at the start of each year, 4 percent of the starting balance. Withdrawals are not adjusted for inflation, and fees and taxes are not included.

Hypothetical annual returns for Portfolio A, years 1 to 20, in percent:

-12, -8, -4, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 10, 9, 8, 7, 6, 8, 7, 9, 10, 12

Portfolio B receives the same 20 returns in reverse order. Without any withdrawals, both portfolios would end at the same value, about $5.63 million. The withdrawals are what make the order matter.

This is a hypothetical illustration for educational purposes only. It does not represent any specific investment or the performance of any YTS portfolio. Actual results will vary.

Why the First Five Years of Retirement Carry the Most Weight

Early losses do the most damage because declines and withdrawals compound together. By year 5, hypothetical Portfolio A has fallen to about $1.28 million. Portfolio B has grown to about $2.59 million. Both have withdrawn the same $400,000.

Each Withdrawal Takes a Larger Share

Once a portfolio is smaller, the same dollar withdrawal is a larger share of what remains. By year 5, the $80,000 withdrawal equals about 6.2 percent of Portfolio A’s balance. For Portfolio B, it equals about 3.1 percent.

Later Gains Compound on a Smaller Base

Portfolio A’s strong final years still add value, but they compound on less money, and the gap never closes. Portfolio B’s losses arrive late, when the balance is large enough to absorb them with less strain.

The Years Just Before Retirement Count Too

A large decline at 63 or 64 can shrink the starting balance for withdrawals. Little time remains to recover before income begins. Some planners describe the years on either side of the retirement date as a single high-risk period.

What Sequence Risk Has Looked Like in Real Markets

Real markets have produced harsher early stretches than this hypothetical. Two periods stand out for anyone who retired near their start.

2000 to 2002

S&P Dow Jones Indices data shows three straight losing years for the S&P 500. Total returns were -9.10 percent, -11.89 percent and -22.10 percent.¹ Compounded, that is a decline of roughly 37.6 percent. A Federal Reserve System review noted the NYSE Composite’s 19.8 percent loss in 2002. It was that index’s largest annual decline since 1974.²

2007 to 2009

The S&P 500’s total return for 2008 was -37.00 percent.¹ S&P Dow Jones Indices measured a 55.25 percent peak-to-trough decline from October 9, 2007, to March 9, 2009.¹ Our guide to investment risk analysis explains how drawdowns like these are measured.

How Sequence Risk Relates to the 4 Percent Guideline

Withdrawal-rate guidelines exist largely because of sequence risk. They aim to set a starting withdrawal that can hold up through weak return sequences, not just average ones.

Morningstar’s research estimated a 3.9 percent starting safe withdrawal rate for 2026.³ Its prior-year analysis assumed a 30-year horizon, a 90 percent probability of success and inflation-adjusted withdrawals.⁴ A shorter horizon or more flexible spending may support a higher rate. For a broader look at income at this asset level, see Can I Retire With $2 Million?

Signs a Retirement Plan May Be More Exposed

Some plans carry more sequence risk than others. These factors may be worth reviewing with a financial professional:

  • A starting withdrawal rate above 4 percent of the portfolio
  • A high stock allocation at or near the retirement date
  • Spending that is mostly fixed and hard to reduce in a down year
  • Few income sources outside the portfolio, such as a pension or Social Security
  • Large planned expenses early in retirement, such as a second home or family gifts

None of these mean a plan will fall short. A federal retiree in the Tysons area with a FERS pension, for example, may rely less on the portfolio.

Approaches People Consider to Help Manage Sequence Risk

No single approach removes sequence risk, but several may help reduce its effect. Each comes with a trade-off, and many plans combine more than one. Suitability depends on your income needs, tax situation and other assets.

Cash Reserve or Bucket Approach

Some retirees set aside one to three years of planned withdrawals in cash or short-term reserves. During a decline, income may come from the reserve rather than from stocks sold at lower prices.

Trade-off: cash may earn less over time, and a long downturn can outlast the reserve.

Flexible Withdrawal Rate

A flexible approach adjusts spending to market results. One example is skipping an inflation increase after a losing year. Another is guardrails that trim withdrawals when the portfolio falls below set levels. Morningstar’s research found flexible methods can support higher starting withdrawals than fixed spending.⁴

Trade-off: income varies from year to year, which may be difficult when fixed expenses are high.

Bond Allocation Glide Path

A glide path shifts the stock and bond mix on a set schedule. One version holds more bonds near the retirement date, then gradually adds stocks as the early years pass.

Trade-off: a more conservative mix may reduce long-term growth potential, and bonds carry interest rate and inflation risk.

Delaying Social Security

For people born in 1943 or later, benefits rise 8 percent for each year claiming is delayed past full retirement age. The increase stops at age 70.⁵ Some households draw more from the portfolio early to fund that delay. See our guide on when to claim Social Security.

Trade-off: portfolio withdrawals rise during the years when sequence risk is highest.

Part-Time or Consulting Income

Earning some income in the first years of retirement may reduce how much the portfolio must supply. That matters most in the period that carries the most weight.

Trade-off: it depends on health, opportunity and preference, and it postpones a full retirement.

For households with $1 million or more, these choices interact with taxes, Roth conversions and account withdrawal order. Private wealth management coordinates them in one plan, rather than one decision at a time.

Listen: How to Make Retirement Last

In Episode 18 of Off the Charts, the YTS team discusses how to make retirement last.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is sequence of returns risk in simple terms?

It is the risk that weak returns arrive at the wrong time. For someone drawing income, early losses can shorten how long savings last, even when long-term average returns are reasonable.

Does sequence of returns risk go away later in retirement?

Its effect is largest early, but it does not disappear. A later decline still reduces the balance, though fewer years of withdrawals remain to compound the shortfall.

Is a 4 percent withdrawal rate still a useful guideline?

It can be a starting point. Morningstar’s research estimated a 3.9 percent starting rate for 2026, with higher rates possible under flexible strategies.³ A financial professional can help test a rate against your own plan.

Can a bucket strategy eliminate sequence of returns risk?

No. A cash reserve may help reduce the need to sell stocks during a decline, but a prolonged downturn can outlast it. It is one tool among several.

How does private wealth management address sequence risk?

A private wealth management team can coordinate withdrawal rates, asset allocation, Social Security timing and tax planning together. The aim is a plan that can adapt if the early years of retirement bring weak markets.

Plan Your Retirement Income With YTS

The first years of retirement leave the least room for a market decline. YTS Wealth Management provides private wealth management for households across the Pittsburgh region and the Tysons, Virginia area. Our team brings financial planning, tax coordination and investment management together in one relationship. We can review how your withdrawal plan may hold up under different market sequences.

Request an Appointment with YTS

This material is for general information only and is not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual. The hypothetical illustration is not representative of any specific investment, and actual results will vary. All investing involves risk, including loss of principal. No strategy assures success or protects against loss. The S&P 500 is an unmanaged index that cannot be invested into directly. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.

References

  1. S&P Dow Jones Indices. S&P 500 Low Volatility Index: Five Decades of History, Exhibits 7 and 8b. January 2020.
  2. Federal Reserve System. Stock Market Report: 2002 Review. Federal Reserve Bank of Boston. January 7, 2003.
  3. Morningstar. The State of Retirement Income for 2026. December 2, 2025.
  4. Morningstar. What’s a Safe Retirement Spending Rate for 2025? Amy Arnott and Jason Kephart.
  5. Social Security Administration. Delayed Retirement Credits.

Sequence of Returns Risk: What It Means for Retirees

Sequence of Returns Risk: What It Means for Retirees

Check the background of investment professionals associated with this site on FINRA’s BrokerCheck